Amanda Purcell’s article “Advancing Climate Assessments: 50 Years of Progress and Impact” offers a thoughtful and informative retrospective on the development of climate assessments over the past fifty years. It emphasizes the key role of the National Academies in shaping both the scientific integrity and practical relevance of these assessments. The article places the history of climate assessments within a broader story of scientific advancement, international collaboration, and the increasing urgency of providing decision-relevant climate information.
The article is strongest when tracing the National Academies’ contributions from their early expert reports in the 1970s and 1980s to their more recent technical reviews of U.S. National Climate Assessments. This historical arc effectively shows how the Academies’ role shifted from synthesizing emerging science to ensuring accuracy, transparency, and usability in federally mandated assessments. By citing specific examples, such as the extensive comments provided on recent National Climate Assessments and the positive conclusion about the 5th NCA’s credibility, the article highlights the Academies’ quiet but essential function as a quality-assurance mechanism for climate science.
The discussion of lessons learned, especially the focus on leadership, stakeholder engagement, science-policy interfaces, and communication strategies, provides additional depth and relevance for today’s practitioners. Equally important is the emphasis on user engagement: recognizing that assessments must not only convey science but also address the needs of decision-makers across government levels, the private sector, and civil society.
That said, while the article does well in documenting institutional milestones and achievements, it is less focused on exploring ongoing challenges. For instance, it does not discuss the political pressures that have occasionally influenced U.S. climate assessments, the difficulty of ensuring that findings are adopted in policymaking, or the unequal access to these reports for vulnerable communities. Addressing these aspects would have added depth to the retrospective by highlighting the limitations and debates surrounding climate assessment processes.
Overall, Purcell’s work succeeds as both a historical overview and an acknowledgment of the thousands of scientists whose collaborative efforts support the credibility of climate assessments. It emphasizes that trusted, science-based information is more essential than ever as climate impacts grow more severe. The article is a valuable addition to understanding not just the origins of climate assessments but also why their ongoing development will be crucial for navigating the decades ahead.
© 2025 National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.
(Source: www.nationalacademies.org/news/2025/08/advancing-climate-assessments-50-years-of-progress-and-impact)
Ready to get started? To learn how ClimaTwin can help you assess the physical and financial impacts of future weather and climate extremes on your infrastructure assets, capital programs, and investment portfolio, please visit www.climatwin.com today.
© 2025 ClimaTwin Corp. All rights reserved worldwide.
ClimaTwin® is a registered trademark of ClimaTwin Corp. The ClimaTwin logos, ClimaTwin Solutions™, Climate Risk Intelligence™, Climate Business Intelligence™, Future-proofing assets today for tomorrow’s climate extremes™ are trademarks of ClimaTwin Corp. All trademarks, service marks, and logos are protected by applicable laws and international treaties, and may not be used without prior written permission of ClimaTwin Corp.
###